Yes. Side-by-side houses routinely read far apart because foundation type, slab condition, sumps, and air handling differ house to house. A neighbor's number describes their basement, not yours.
More detail
Kansas City streets make the point vividly because eras mix: a Prairie Village block can hold a 1948 Cape Cod on block walls, a 1952 ranch with a later sump, and a rebuilt infill on poured concrete, three different soil-gas machines wearing similar siding. Even identical floor plans diverge underground, where one slab cracked and one did not, one pit got a sealed lid and one got plywood, one furnace return leaks basement air and one is tight. The soil itself shifts across short distances too, with sand lenses and clay pockets changing how freely gas moves laterally, so two houses can sit over genuinely different gas supplies. The statistics follow: in the KDHE and K-State Kansas dataset, 43 percent of measurements came in at or above 4 pCi/L, which means neighbors above and below the line sit on the same streets everywhere in the metro. A kit costs $15 to $30 and answers the only relevant question. Place it per the DIY guide, or book a professional test.